I remember the first time I realized that race "meant" something to people. I don't like to use the term "color blind," but I have always noticed race the way I notice that the sky is blue or cloudy, and that the grass is green- it's just a part of life. I was 6 and in the 1st grade, and my Girl Scout Troop was headed to our meeting place for our weekly meet-up. We met in a neighborhood club house that was across the street, so we walked most of the time. In true Girl Scout fashion, we utilized the buddy system and were all told to grab someone's hand. Growing up in West Cobb County in the 90s and 2000s, the demographic consisted mostly of white, middle-class families (although this demographic changed over the course of my time in school). We had one African American in our troop, I'll call her Sally. I knew Sally was black, but I knew I was white- it was just the way things were, and I liked Sally just the same. When it was time to pair up, Sally went to grab another girl's hand as her buddy. This young lady turned away from Sally, looked at our troop leaders and said, "I don't hold those people's hands." One of our leaders quickly stepped in without missing a beat and said, "Well Sally is such a sweet girl, I'd like to be the one to hold her hand today."
In my 6 year old brain I went through the reasons someone wouldn't want to hold Sally's hand- she didn't smell funny, she wasn't mean, she didn't say things that were "weird." The only difference was that Sally was black.
I grew up in a home where race was discussed, but I had never heard of white privilege until I went to college. I'll start by saying that I consider myself conservative politically, but I'm more of an "independent." I always tend to vote for the lesser of two evils because I never 100% agree with everything a politician stands for, especially when it comes to education reform. There are some things I'm more liberal about, and some I'm conservative about. This concept of white privilege kind of threw me for a loop- I've faced adversity. My dad died when I was 6 (I was there), I found my grandmother dead Christmas morning when I was 13, I knew we sometimes struggled financially as a single-parent household, I was putting myself through college, and I felt I had rightfully earned everything I had accomplished in life. I had no idea that many of these things came easily to me because I was white. When these discussions started I was kind of hurt and felt like anyone could pick themselves up by their bootstraps- it was the American way.
It all started to make sense when I read a list of products that are catered toward white people that people of color are not given "access" (for lack of a better word) to. This list included things like the fact that people of color couldn't find their favorite foods at the grocery store, or that it was found in the ethnic foods aisle, that hair care products were found in the ethnic hair care aisle- as if everyone who isn't white is labeled as "ethnic." I had noticed these things, but it all came down to a band-aid.
Yes, a band-aid. I had never thought about the fact that band-aids are marketed as "flesh toned," and they all come in various shades of peach. As if the only color of flesh there is has a peach undertone. This is where it hit me- I can go out and easily find something to match my "flesh tone," but not everyone else can. This was my "ah-ha" moment, if you will.
My next big wake up call came when I was student teaching in Rockdale County. I was in a Title 1 area, and out of 180 students, about 15 of them were white. I remember noticing this, but again, not thinking anything of it. It wasn't until a fellow RA, who is black, asked me if I felt like I was able to connect with all of my black students. I had been at the school for about 6 weeks at that point and thought that my lack of connecting was because I was timid and learning the ropes. I didn't think about the fact that I was a young, white, middle class college student and to many students I didn't "get" them. I can also say this freely because as I got to know these students, many of them told me this information. It wasn't until I took the time to connect with them, which one day came in the form of me singing the Fresh Prince lyrics, or telling them that I'd lost my dad at a young age, that they realized they could trust me. At times this has nothing to do with race, but mostly the fact that many of my students had been let down by adults in their lives and now knew they had an adult who loved them and valued them.
This last year as a first year teacher was tough. Amidst me trying to figure out what I was doing, topics came up such as Ferguson, Eric Garner, and more. It's difficult to figure out where I'm crossing the line as an educator- are these things their parents intentionally don't want them to know about the world? But then I think that they're 13 and 14 and see more on social media than I ever thought possible. I remember reading an article about the impact of social media- we were discussing Michael Brown and how the media took to his Facebook immediately after the shooting and showed pictures of his underage drinking, but also how his family posted a picture of him in his cap and gown. Two very different pictures of the same young man. In order to put my toe in the water of these class discussions, I chose to focus on the social media presence of it rather than race (call it a cop- out, I was trying to get to know my students and see if I received parent back lash). However, obviously race came up, and I discussed it the best way I knew how. It all came home when a student raised her hand and said, "What's going on in Ferguson? I thought racism stopped when the Civil Rights Movement ended." I should note that this came from an African American student and that I currently teach in a more affluent area than during my student teaching. Many of my students are fortunate to not have personally experienced side effects of racism, which became evident when a student made a snarky comment to another student and I said, "Well aren't you the pot calling the kettle black?" and they told me that was a racist comment. This then spurred a discussion about what racism truly is.
Now, as I watch with sadness in my heart over the recent events in Charleston, I think of how I could make that a teachable moment. Events like these aren't going to end. I watch with sadness as people fight back and forth with each other on social media about white privilege and race. These events such as Ferguson, Eric Garner, Baltimore, and Charleston are crimes committed against humanity. We are all human, regardless of skin color. This hatred comes from generations of ignorance and the lack of evolving in ideals and morals. I had a student this year tell me I should apologize to him because my family owned slaves. I looked at him and told him that half of my family was still in Europe until the 1900s and hadn't yet immigrated to the US, and the others lived in the north. My aunt recently did an ancestry search and we were never slave owners (we executed Native Americans instead- note with irony). He told me it didn't matter and I was white and should apologize. That student also displayed ignorance in that comment because he was raised to believe that most white people were out to get him and that he was owed an apology from me and other whites. This student was an absolute pill and one I am glad is gone (he also announced to the class that I grew up poor because we didn't have internet prior to 1997, despite the fact that I told him NO ONE had the internet, but I digress). Ignorance isn't one-sided.
My hope as an educator is that I can have
constructive conversations with my students because racism and privilege DO exist. My students and I discussed white privilege and I flat-out told them that some things came more easily to me because I was white and unfortunately that was the way things worked, but that we can change things. It starts with a refusal to be ignorant. The issue with many of my students is that they were never given the platform to ask questions about race without it getting hostile. We remain ignorant when questions aren't asked. Issues such as these involve intense emotions, but nothing will ever change or get accomplished if we refuse to listen to each other's concerns and ideas. I think we need to let Ferguson, Baltimore, Charleston, and countless other cities be examples of teachable moments. It's difficult because we will never know what really happened in any of these situations because human error exists- people lie, get confused, and make mistakes. It's hard to know the news when we have different perspectives coming from so many media outlets. We're doing an injustice to all of the people who fought in past generations when we refuse to listen to each other. My favorite line from Martin Luther King, Jr.'s "Letter From Birmingham Jail" is "Injustice
anywhere is a threat to justice
everywhere" (my emphasis added). I look at what's happening in America and can make a list of a hundred different teachable moments, but I'll never be able to reach each of my students, or all of the students in my school, for that matter. We all have demons; we all have baggage; we all are fighting battles no one knows about. If we could just take the time to sit down and have honest conversations with ourselves and others without getting hostile and defensive things might be different. I only hope and pray that by providing an environment such as that for my students, that maybe a spark with occur and some change can happen when they go throughout their daily lives.
But for now, I hope I can make this yet another teachable moment.